I've been a devoted follower and cynic of the Progressive Intelligence and Opinion blog for many months now. There are many things that we disagree on, and a few things that agree on. This post is about one of the things we disagree on. Really disagree on. His new post, "Mindblowing inequality isn't just unfair but inefficient!"
(Never mind the fact that "mindblowing" isn't one word)
From what I've read about him he was born in the U.S., grew up in Germany, and moved back here, fully indoctrinated with that good ol' European socialist attitude.
He's had many-a post about the travesty of income inequality. With this blog, I'll show that not only are most claims of income inequality and wealth distribution grossly overstated, but that rich people being rich doesn't cause poor people to be poor. Imagine that.
Here are some income distribution facts from the U.S. Census Bureau.
Household Income Group % of Total Income Income Range
Lowest 20%------3.4%------$0-18,500
Second 20%------8.7%------$18,500-34,738
Third 20%--------14.7%-----$34,738-55,331
Fourth 20%------23.2%-----$55,331-88,030
Highest 20%-----50.1%-----$88,030 and up
The top 20% has roughly 14 times the total share of money than the bottom 20%. For a comparison, in 1971, the top 20% had only 11 times the share of total money than the bottom 20%.
But why is this? Is the same old saying "The rich get richer and the poor get poorer" true? Well, while a rich person has more money to invest (more on savings amounts later), and thus more of an opportunity to invest and earn more interest than someone at the bottom, income inequality has not risen by that much over the course of the 33 years in question.
The overstating of income inequality in our country is due in large part to two factors:
1. Measurements of inequality don't take into account in-kind transfers (medical assistance, food stamps, etc.).
2. The inequality expressed was taken from one point in time.
There are other things that come into play, such as immigrants and mindsets.
The steady increase in income inequality in recent decades is due largely to increased immigration. Between 1970 and 2000, foreign-born population in our great country increased from 9.6 million to 31.1 million. The percentage of the U.S. population that is foreign-born increased from 4.7% in 1970 to 11.1% in 2000.
Immigrants' median annual income is about 15% lower than native-born Americans. This is why the gap between the top and bottom groups has increased.
However, income is even more equally distributed after taking out taxes and in-kind (food stamps, medical assistance, etc.) transfer payments. The current measure of inequality is skewed by this lack of inclusion.
Higher incomes pay a higher percentage of their income in federal taxes, but in-kind transfers are received disproportionately by lower income households.
Another way that inequality is overstated is that the distribution of money income expressed above overstates the actual degree of income inequality by focusing on income distribution at one point in time.
A large chunk of the people in the lowest 20% of households are young people at the start of their careers. Most of these young people will move into higher income groups as their careers progress and they develop more human capital (developed ability that increases a person's productivity).
If career incomes were compared or if incomes were compared for households at the same career stage the gap between the highest and lowest would be much smaller.
Wealth distribution is also overstated. This is caused by the measure of wealth distribution comparing different people at different career stages. Comparing the wealth of a 60-year-old to the wealth of a 25-year-old overstates the inequality.
Wealth distribution is also overstated because human capital is NOT included in measuring wealth. For most people, their human capital is the most valuable asset owned. An example would be a 25-year-old recent Harvard Law School grad may have very little accumulated wealth in terms of physical assets, but the Harvard Law degree is very valuable human capital.
These are the causes of the continuing income inequality, which people might find interesting.
1. Natural ability: Some people are born with skills in math, music, or athletics. A person with a high level of marketable natural ability may earn a higher income than a person with a lower level of natural ability.
2. Human capital: Mean earning increase as education levels rise, but, again, a degree in chemical engineering and a degree in elementary education will have different earning potential in the marketplace.
3. Work and leisure choices: Contrary to popular belief rich people don't just sit back and make money off the backs of hardworking proletarians. Most people who've accumulated much wealth and have high earning potential have worked incredibly hard for it.
4. Risk taking: People differ in their willingness to take risks. An example would be that self-employed entrepreneurs make up a disproportionately large share of society's millionaires, but they also make up a disproportionately large share of those filling for bankruptcy.
5. Employment discrimination: This occurs when employees make hiring, promotion, and pay decisions based on factors unrelated to employee productivity.
6. Luck: A person can have good luck (winning the lottery) or bad luck (suffering a debilitating illness). Most people experience a mix of good and bad luck.
There will always be poverty, because honestly a lot of it has to do with how impoverished people think. They don't seek out wealth, but rather they tend to think that wealth shows up on its own. Wealth doesn't just come up and bite you on the butt, contrary to popular belief it seems.
Wealthy people aren't born trust fund babies 100% of the time; in fact it's quite the contrary. 90% of all millionaires in the U.S. are first generation, which means they left the cave, killed it, and brought it home. Their thought processes are different from people living in perpetual poverty. If you wants some more information about what the typical millionaire is really like check out Thomas J. Stanley's books The Millionaire Next Door and The Millionaire Mind.
Poverty isn't the fault of government and it's certainly not the fault of rich people. The majority of the problem rests with the people. The government and the already-wealthy are just easy targets.
The wealthy also differ in their savings rate. The average millionaire focuses on saving, investing, and building wealth, and not on spending their money on frivolous items. It is much easier for the wealthy to save money, as they need only save a small percentage of income rather than the larger chunk that must be saved by people with lesser incomes.
So again, don't buy into the fact that millionaires are automatically evil. Most are self-made, first generation, good-hearted people who live in modest houses, drive used cars, and take the time to learn about wise investing.
I'll leave you with this: Making rich people poorer doesn't make poor people richer.
So take your God damned socialism back to the Old World, buddy.
Sunday, June 1, 2008
Monday, April 14, 2008
Obama's Answer
A quickie here.
I'm watching CNN's "Compassion Forum" and Barack Obama and he was asked what he would do to reduce poverty in our great country.
Before he even opened his mouth I knew where he would go with his answer.
He talked briefly about the banking industry, but quickly went on to the tax code.
He talked about how people at the bottom pay too much and how George Bush's "tax cuts for the rich" were hurting the lower and middle classes. Now, for now we'll forget that Bush's tax cuts lowered not only the top rate from 39.5% to 35%, but also lowered the bottom rate from 15% to 10%.
Let's forget all of that for a second. How does giving people at the top tax cuts hurt poor people? Other than decreased government revenue, how is that directly affecting people at the bottom? It doesn't. The reason that tax breaks for the rich haven't worked in the past three decades was because the revenue cuts weren't met with cuts in government spending.
Let's just make this clear: Making the rich poorer does not make the poor richer.
I just had to get that off of my chest.
I'm watching CNN's "Compassion Forum" and Barack Obama and he was asked what he would do to reduce poverty in our great country.
Before he even opened his mouth I knew where he would go with his answer.
He talked briefly about the banking industry, but quickly went on to the tax code.
He talked about how people at the bottom pay too much and how George Bush's "tax cuts for the rich" were hurting the lower and middle classes. Now, for now we'll forget that Bush's tax cuts lowered not only the top rate from 39.5% to 35%, but also lowered the bottom rate from 15% to 10%.
Let's forget all of that for a second. How does giving people at the top tax cuts hurt poor people? Other than decreased government revenue, how is that directly affecting people at the bottom? It doesn't. The reason that tax breaks for the rich haven't worked in the past three decades was because the revenue cuts weren't met with cuts in government spending.
Let's just make this clear: Making the rich poorer does not make the poor richer.
I just had to get that off of my chest.
Wednesday, April 2, 2008
People make stupid decisions.
It's a fact of life that people are inevitably going to make stupid decisions. Kids do it, teens do it, adults do it, and seniors do it. Republicans do it, Democrats do it, Socialists do it (a lot),
and independents do it. Every race does it, every religion does it, every government does it, and every meteorologist does it. There is no way around making stupid decisions.
But the mistakes I'm talking about today were made by people who are on the news all the time and yet are never named. They are the people that are facing foreclosure because they got into a house they couldn't afford.
Now before I get the liberal smack down argument that the predatory mortgage lenders are at fault, let me say that I halfway agree. The mortgage companies are like a good portions of Americans; they think about the short term, not the long term.
The problem that many people are facing these days with their homes is a big one, and apparently one that the government thinks they need to solve. More on that later.
***Let me make it clear that the "crisis" only pertains to sub-prime mortgages. Foreclosures are up for people who borrowed sub-prime loans, but not for regular, traditional mortgages.***
I've heard many arguments about who's at fault for the sub-prime mortgage crisis. The lenders, the government, the Fed, and I've even heard the nation's rich people are to blame because they make the people who don't have as much money envy them.
Like I said above, the blame partially resides with the unethical lenders, who in order to make a quick buck lent money to people who couldn't afford the payments or the principal. But the main blame resides with the people who borrowed the money.
They weren't forced to borrow the money, they were just mislead by what we many call the "right" of all Americans to own homes.
Owning a home isn't a right in America, it's a privilege for those who earn it and can afford it.
We've become a nation of "gimmees" and takers. A good portion of the population it seems thinks that everything needs to be handed to them by the government and that rich people should foot the bill for their wants. I, of course, am completely against this way of thinking.
I don't see why people think that the government needs to intervene with everything. People think they need to stop the recession and that they need to stop the mass foreclosure. I just can't help but wonder why. Why is it the government's responsibility to help people that made stupid decisions? IT'S NOT! It's that simple.
I'm sure if you ask around you can find many people age 25 and older who got themselves into deep trouble and had their parents refuse to help them., and I guarantee you that whatever that experience was it made them stronger, more responsible, and more apt to deal with their problems themselves instead of relying on other people to bail them out. There should be more accountability with people that make stupid decisions.
I know it sounds mean, but people need to face the consequences of their actions, and if that involves losing their house and having to start from scratch then so be it. It will make them stronger, more appreciative of things they have, and much smarter about how they go about it the next time around.
I think that Americans' collective idea that we deserve everything is partially to blame for this problem of buying things we know we can't afford. That's why the average American has around $9,000 in unsecured credit card debt.
We Americans have lost sight of the old way of doing things. We used to buy frugally. We used to pay for things with cash only. Hell, people used to save up and buy houses with cash! Imagine how many people would make fun of you if you did that today.
"Well that's stupid! Why are you doing that? You'll lose your tax break! C'mon, lemme show you how it's done..."
America, here's a piece of advice that a very smart and responsible man once told me: Don't take money advice from broke people.
Okay, so Dave Ramsey didn't say that just to me, but it's a good message nonetheless.
Just because you work hard doesn't mean that you deserve a house. You deserve it when you can afford it. And if you do make a stupid decision, you should deal with the consequences, not have the government bail you out.
Here's a little example of how one decision in your life can either make it great or make it regrettable.
In an economics class I heard the story of a 22 year old whose dad recently passed away. His son was the sole beneficiary of his $250,000 life insurance policy. Now what do you think would happen if you received $250,000 when you were 22?
He had two paths in front of him.
Path 1:
He could keep his job and continue school and take out$30,000 to pay for the rest of his college education.
250,000 - 30,000= 220,000
He could move out of his apartment and put a half-price down payment on a nice $150,000 house.
220,000 - 75,000 = 145,000
He could put $15,000 in a money market account or CD ladder as an emergency fund, reinvesting the interest.
145,000 - 15,000 = 130,000
He could then invest the remaining $130,000 in safe, growth stock mutual funds at a very realistic average of 12% until he retires at the age of 65.
130,000 x (1.12)^43 = 16,994,888
That's $16,994,888 that he'll have when he retires. If he continues school, gets his degree, at age 24 and finds a good job he could contribute $400 a month into mutual funds until he retires.
((400 x (1.01)^(41 x 12)) - 1)/.01 = 5,307,809
5,307,809 + 16,994,888 = 22,302,697
He would have $22,302,697 at age 65 before taxes just for making good decisions.
Unfortunately he didn't choose that path.
Path 2:
He chose this path.
He took the $250,000 and right off bought a $60,000 Ford Mustang Shelby GT500.
250,000 - 60,000 = 190,000
He then bought a $175,000 house.
190,000 - 175,000 = 15,000
Then, by the time he was done buying video games, booze, computers, and iPods, he only had about $1,000.
But don't worry. He did what he thought was the smart thing to do and put the rest of the money in his savings account with a 1% APY. So in 43 years he'll have $1,043.92. Boy, that's smart.
My point is that we all make stupid decisions. Whether it's turning what was meant to be a blessing into a bunch of useless things or buying a house that you can't afford, you shouldn't expect the government to bail you out for your stupid decisions.
and independents do it. Every race does it, every religion does it, every government does it, and every meteorologist does it. There is no way around making stupid decisions.
But the mistakes I'm talking about today were made by people who are on the news all the time and yet are never named. They are the people that are facing foreclosure because they got into a house they couldn't afford.
Now before I get the liberal smack down argument that the predatory mortgage lenders are at fault, let me say that I halfway agree. The mortgage companies are like a good portions of Americans; they think about the short term, not the long term.
The problem that many people are facing these days with their homes is a big one, and apparently one that the government thinks they need to solve. More on that later.
***Let me make it clear that the "crisis" only pertains to sub-prime mortgages. Foreclosures are up for people who borrowed sub-prime loans, but not for regular, traditional mortgages.***
I've heard many arguments about who's at fault for the sub-prime mortgage crisis. The lenders, the government, the Fed, and I've even heard the nation's rich people are to blame because they make the people who don't have as much money envy them.
Like I said above, the blame partially resides with the unethical lenders, who in order to make a quick buck lent money to people who couldn't afford the payments or the principal. But the main blame resides with the people who borrowed the money.
They weren't forced to borrow the money, they were just mislead by what we many call the "right" of all Americans to own homes.
Owning a home isn't a right in America, it's a privilege for those who earn it and can afford it.
We've become a nation of "gimmees" and takers. A good portion of the population it seems thinks that everything needs to be handed to them by the government and that rich people should foot the bill for their wants. I, of course, am completely against this way of thinking.
I don't see why people think that the government needs to intervene with everything. People think they need to stop the recession and that they need to stop the mass foreclosure. I just can't help but wonder why. Why is it the government's responsibility to help people that made stupid decisions? IT'S NOT! It's that simple.
I'm sure if you ask around you can find many people age 25 and older who got themselves into deep trouble and had their parents refuse to help them., and I guarantee you that whatever that experience was it made them stronger, more responsible, and more apt to deal with their problems themselves instead of relying on other people to bail them out. There should be more accountability with people that make stupid decisions.
I know it sounds mean, but people need to face the consequences of their actions, and if that involves losing their house and having to start from scratch then so be it. It will make them stronger, more appreciative of things they have, and much smarter about how they go about it the next time around.
I think that Americans' collective idea that we deserve everything is partially to blame for this problem of buying things we know we can't afford. That's why the average American has around $9,000 in unsecured credit card debt.
We Americans have lost sight of the old way of doing things. We used to buy frugally. We used to pay for things with cash only. Hell, people used to save up and buy houses with cash! Imagine how many people would make fun of you if you did that today.
"Well that's stupid! Why are you doing that? You'll lose your tax break! C'mon, lemme show you how it's done..."
America, here's a piece of advice that a very smart and responsible man once told me: Don't take money advice from broke people.
Okay, so Dave Ramsey didn't say that just to me, but it's a good message nonetheless.
Just because you work hard doesn't mean that you deserve a house. You deserve it when you can afford it. And if you do make a stupid decision, you should deal with the consequences, not have the government bail you out.
Here's a little example of how one decision in your life can either make it great or make it regrettable.
In an economics class I heard the story of a 22 year old whose dad recently passed away. His son was the sole beneficiary of his $250,000 life insurance policy. Now what do you think would happen if you received $250,000 when you were 22?
He had two paths in front of him.
Path 1:
He could keep his job and continue school and take out$30,000 to pay for the rest of his college education.
250,000 - 30,000= 220,000
He could move out of his apartment and put a half-price down payment on a nice $150,000 house.
220,000 - 75,000 = 145,000
He could put $15,000 in a money market account or CD ladder as an emergency fund, reinvesting the interest.
145,000 - 15,000 = 130,000
He could then invest the remaining $130,000 in safe, growth stock mutual funds at a very realistic average of 12% until he retires at the age of 65.
130,000 x (1.12)^43 = 16,994,888
That's $16,994,888 that he'll have when he retires. If he continues school, gets his degree, at age 24 and finds a good job he could contribute $400 a month into mutual funds until he retires.
((400 x (1.01)^(41 x 12)) - 1)/.01 = 5,307,809
5,307,809 + 16,994,888 = 22,302,697
He would have $22,302,697 at age 65 before taxes just for making good decisions.
Unfortunately he didn't choose that path.
Path 2:
He chose this path.
He took the $250,000 and right off bought a $60,000 Ford Mustang Shelby GT500.
250,000 - 60,000 = 190,000
He then bought a $175,000 house.
190,000 - 175,000 = 15,000
Then, by the time he was done buying video games, booze, computers, and iPods, he only had about $1,000.
But don't worry. He did what he thought was the smart thing to do and put the rest of the money in his savings account with a 1% APY. So in 43 years he'll have $1,043.92. Boy, that's smart.
My point is that we all make stupid decisions. Whether it's turning what was meant to be a blessing into a bunch of useless things or buying a house that you can't afford, you shouldn't expect the government to bail you out for your stupid decisions.
Friday, March 14, 2008
Quiz
I found this funny little quiz on another blog. But it originally came from here.
1) "We're going to take things away from you on behalf of the common good."
A. Karl Marx
B. Adolph Hitler
C. Joseph Stalin
D. None of the above
2) "It's time for a new beginning, for an end to government of the few, by the few, and for the few...and to replace it with shared responsibility for shared prosperity."
A. Lenin
B. Mussolini
C. Idi Amin
D. None of the Above
3) "(We)...can't just let business as usual go on, and that means something has to be taken away from some people."
A. Nikita Khrushev
B. Jose f Goebbels
C. Boris Yeltsin
D. None of the above
4) "We have to build a political consensus and that requires people to give up a little bit of their own...in order to create this common ground."
A. Mao Tse Dung
B. Hugo Chavez
C. Kim Jong Il
D. None of the above
5) "I certainly think the free-market has failed."
A. Karl Marx
B. Lenin
C. Molotov
D. None of the above
6) "I think it's time to send a clear message to what has become the most profitable sector in (the) entire economy that they are being watched."
A. Pinochet
B. Milosevic
C. Saddam Hussein
D. None of the above
Answers:
(1) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/29/2004
(2) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 5/29/2007
(3) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(4) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(5) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(6) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 9/2/2005
I couldn't help but laugh at how true it is. Of course most of her supporters will say those quotes were taken out of context, and they were, but the tone of the entire speech reflects the quotes perfectly.
"It's time for a new beginning, for an end to government of the few, by the few, and for the few, time to reject the idea of an "on your own"society and to replace it with shared responsibility for shared prosperity. I prefer a "we're all in it together" society. I believe our government can once again work for all Americans. It can promote the great American tradition of opportunity for all and special privileges for none." -Hillary Clinton May 29th, 2007
Expect a new post about income inequality and the reason it's increased within the next few days. Cheers.
1) "We're going to take things away from you on behalf of the common good."
A. Karl Marx
B. Adolph Hitler
C. Joseph Stalin
D. None of the above
2) "It's time for a new beginning, for an end to government of the few, by the few, and for the few...and to replace it with shared responsibility for shared prosperity."
A. Lenin
B. Mussolini
C. Idi Amin
D. None of the Above
3) "(We)...can't just let business as usual go on, and that means something has to be taken away from some people."
A. Nikita Khrushev
B. Jose f Goebbels
C. Boris Yeltsin
D. None of the above
4) "We have to build a political consensus and that requires people to give up a little bit of their own...in order to create this common ground."
A. Mao Tse Dung
B. Hugo Chavez
C. Kim Jong Il
D. None of the above
5) "I certainly think the free-market has failed."
A. Karl Marx
B. Lenin
C. Molotov
D. None of the above
6) "I think it's time to send a clear message to what has become the most profitable sector in (the) entire economy that they are being watched."
A. Pinochet
B. Milosevic
C. Saddam Hussein
D. None of the above
Answers:
(1) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/29/2004
(2) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 5/29/2007
(3) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(4) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(5) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(6) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 9/2/2005
I couldn't help but laugh at how true it is. Of course most of her supporters will say those quotes were taken out of context, and they were, but the tone of the entire speech reflects the quotes perfectly.
"It's time for a new beginning, for an end to government of the few, by the few, and for the few, time to reject the idea of an "on your own"society and to replace it with shared responsibility for shared prosperity. I prefer a "we're all in it together" society. I believe our government can once again work for all Americans. It can promote the great American tradition of opportunity for all and special privileges for none." -Hillary Clinton May 29th, 2007
Expect a new post about income inequality and the reason it's increased within the next few days. Cheers.
Monday, March 3, 2008
Aren't politics odd?
They are, and they're endlessly fascinating for me. I find it a bit amusing how people have voted so far in the primaries.
The conservatives haven't elected a conservative, and the liberals have gone incredibly far to the left (straight into socialist territory).
I ponder to myself why the Democrats would be fighting it out to elect a candidate so far to the left. Could it be that Obama and Clinton are the farthest away from the evil right, so they must be good? Maybe. Have the Democrats stopped thinking clearly and started to bow down for European-type socialism? Possibly. But I think that the real problem here is the left's hard on for pointless rhetoric. The right has this problem too, but it's not as bad as what we've seen lately with the Democrats.
Buzzwords like "hope" and "change" have become big, well, issues for the Democrats. This is all well and good, but shouldn't there be a little more substance in their campaigns? Promises of universal healthcare, getting the troops out of Iraq, their version of "fiscal responsibly" (which is their way of saying they'll be spending just as much as the current administration, but in different, much more popular areas).
It troubles me that in one of the early Democratic debates all of the candidates were asked a simple question: Raise your hand if balancing the federal budget is going to be one of your top priorities. I believe only two people raised their hands, and they weren't Obama or Clinton.
I'm a libertarian with very conservative fiscal views and some fairly liberal social views. Here's how my tiny little brain works:
1. Universal healthcare won't work
2. We need out of Iraq. Not because the strategy is not working, but because we can't afford it.
3. We need to cut spending. I'm talking CUTTING spending. The defense budget is obscene. We can protect our great country in a much more fiscally responsible fashion.
4. Pay our soldiers more and stop sending the National Guard troops overseas. Our troops risk their lives, come home, and are refused healthcare? This is shameful.
5. Stop socialism. I know that socialism has become a buzz-word that's not paid attention to, but we need to take a look at ourselves and think about why we're supporting socialist candidates. I'm not against all socialist programs. I love the postal service! They always get my Car & Driver to me on time. But that's about where I draw the line.
6. No more redistribution of wealth. I know that CEOs get paid too much, but unless you're a stockholder of that CEO's company, it's none of your business.
What's mine is mine. What's yours is yours. What's theirs is not ours. What's ours is not theirs.
How hard is that to understand? You're not entitled to my income, no matter how superfluous it is. You have no constitutional right to it, you have no moral right to it. If I chose to donate my money to worthy causes, that's my business. If I want to give my children my fortune, that's my business. If I want to give my family a large gift, that's my business. If I want to spend ludicrous amounts of my money buying expensive things for myself while other people can't afford to go to college, as big of a jerk as it makes me sound, that's MY BUSINESS.
It's none of your business, you're not entitled to my money, and your high taxes on income, both personal and corporate are hurting America. Oh snap, I said it.
Why is it that companies are moving their workforce to other countries? Yes, it is partly because of cheap labor, but I'd venture to guess that the main reason companies decide to make the switch is because the place in which they're moving has a much lower corporate income tax than America's. If we, I don't know, cut the corporate income tax rates they might be inclined to stay here despite the lack of cheap labor.
But back to the question I raised earlier.
Why is that the two parties are electing people who harbor views that are either very extreme (obama and Clinton) or very soft (McCain). McCain's views are not exactly the most conservative.
So why are we electing these people?
Comment and tell me what your opinions are.
By the way, I'm still rooting for Ron Paul. It's a shame he's been panned by the media powers to be.
The conservatives haven't elected a conservative, and the liberals have gone incredibly far to the left (straight into socialist territory).
I ponder to myself why the Democrats would be fighting it out to elect a candidate so far to the left. Could it be that Obama and Clinton are the farthest away from the evil right, so they must be good? Maybe. Have the Democrats stopped thinking clearly and started to bow down for European-type socialism? Possibly. But I think that the real problem here is the left's hard on for pointless rhetoric. The right has this problem too, but it's not as bad as what we've seen lately with the Democrats.
Buzzwords like "hope" and "change" have become big, well, issues for the Democrats. This is all well and good, but shouldn't there be a little more substance in their campaigns? Promises of universal healthcare, getting the troops out of Iraq, their version of "fiscal responsibly" (which is their way of saying they'll be spending just as much as the current administration, but in different, much more popular areas).
It troubles me that in one of the early Democratic debates all of the candidates were asked a simple question: Raise your hand if balancing the federal budget is going to be one of your top priorities. I believe only two people raised their hands, and they weren't Obama or Clinton.
I'm a libertarian with very conservative fiscal views and some fairly liberal social views. Here's how my tiny little brain works:
1. Universal healthcare won't work
2. We need out of Iraq. Not because the strategy is not working, but because we can't afford it.
3. We need to cut spending. I'm talking CUTTING spending. The defense budget is obscene. We can protect our great country in a much more fiscally responsible fashion.
4. Pay our soldiers more and stop sending the National Guard troops overseas. Our troops risk their lives, come home, and are refused healthcare? This is shameful.
5. Stop socialism. I know that socialism has become a buzz-word that's not paid attention to, but we need to take a look at ourselves and think about why we're supporting socialist candidates. I'm not against all socialist programs. I love the postal service! They always get my Car & Driver to me on time. But that's about where I draw the line.
6. No more redistribution of wealth. I know that CEOs get paid too much, but unless you're a stockholder of that CEO's company, it's none of your business.
What's mine is mine. What's yours is yours. What's theirs is not ours. What's ours is not theirs.
How hard is that to understand? You're not entitled to my income, no matter how superfluous it is. You have no constitutional right to it, you have no moral right to it. If I chose to donate my money to worthy causes, that's my business. If I want to give my children my fortune, that's my business. If I want to give my family a large gift, that's my business. If I want to spend ludicrous amounts of my money buying expensive things for myself while other people can't afford to go to college, as big of a jerk as it makes me sound, that's MY BUSINESS.
It's none of your business, you're not entitled to my money, and your high taxes on income, both personal and corporate are hurting America. Oh snap, I said it.
Why is it that companies are moving their workforce to other countries? Yes, it is partly because of cheap labor, but I'd venture to guess that the main reason companies decide to make the switch is because the place in which they're moving has a much lower corporate income tax than America's. If we, I don't know, cut the corporate income tax rates they might be inclined to stay here despite the lack of cheap labor.
But back to the question I raised earlier.
Why is that the two parties are electing people who harbor views that are either very extreme (obama and Clinton) or very soft (McCain). McCain's views are not exactly the most conservative.
So why are we electing these people?
Comment and tell me what your opinions are.
By the way, I'm still rooting for Ron Paul. It's a shame he's been panned by the media powers to be.
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Tax the rich!!!
Tax the rich!!!
This is the battle-cry of the two remaining Democratic presidential candidates. Sounds good right?
I mean, think about it. Those damn richers make so much, and they're all evil. Every cent of their fortune is somehow stolen from us folks at the bottom. We need retribution! They make too much! They don't deserve it! KILL!
This little ditty is sung in many-a middle-class home. Should we blame them for thinking this way? No. I mean growing up I was always told that life isn't fair, and it isn't. But should we really be taxing the rich on general principle? I don't think so. There are so many loopholes in our much-too-extensive tax code for the rich. You know what I say? Stop bitching about it and fix it! I see the loopholes as a sort of built in, accidental anti-socialism device. But there is a serious injustice that the rich pay less than a lot of middle-class families do.
But what to do... What to do...
In a perfect world we wouldn't have the government taxing our money that we earn. But Ron Paul has no chance, so we can forget this.
How about the FairTax? I personally don't like it.
Taxes on consumption are regressive, but this is remedied by a tax pre-bate, making it a fairly progressive structure. It would most likely fall of near the top of the ladder and the middle-class would end up paying a bulk of the taxes.
The real reason I don't like it is admittedly a little selfish. I'm in college and due to student loans my net worth is in the red. I don't want to have to pay a 23% premium on my various retail purchases at this point in my life. Or ever really.
So what about the flat tax? A 10% federal flat tax on every earner's income. How about we sweeten the deal? Let's let everyone with an income lower than $35,000 pay no federal income taxes.
$0-$35,000: 0%
But wait, there's more. How about in the $35,000 to $80,000 bracket we only put that up to 5%
$0-$35,000: 0%
$35,001-$80,000: 5%
It gets better. Everything above $80,000 is taxed at 10%. No matter if you make $90,000 to $1.2 million.
Okay, so it's not a flat-tax anymore, but it's a nice compromise. Well hell, it's the only progressive tax I'd ever endorse.
What's that? You say it's not fair that someone can make more money than you and pay the same taxes? Suck it up and innovate. Work that brain of yours, find a way to better the world and make yourself a profit.
If you want to make millions but the corporate ladder is just too big, then quit your whining and do something productive. Don't just be jealous at the CEOs who make $38 million a year.
You say they're overpaid? Yeah they are. Why don't you buy some stock in the company and go to some stockholder conferences and express your concern.
Before we all cry out "tax the rich more" we need to be looking at all of the problems.
- The government needs to spend less. Yeah, this means cutting back on unnecessary programs, which includes a lot of wasteful social programs.
Before you go calling me a horrible person without a heart let me say this: I'm not against social programs for the truly needy, the truly disabled, or the truly sick. Medicare, Medicaid, Disability; I'm not against these. My father paid into the system his entire life and became medically disabled (the real kind, not the 'I slipped in Wal-Mart' kind). He's on disability. Anybody who pays into the system and can truly not work is entitled to the money they were forced to pay in. Medicare and Medicaid need to be managed more efficiently. Social security needs to be partially privatized. We need to stop electing people who are hemorrhaging our tax dollars away on pet projects and unnecessary wars.
- We need to stop with the jealousy.
It's an epidemic in this country. I'm a dirt poor 21 year old who's financing his college education. Have an image of me yet? Well, let me alter it. I've started up two business since I was 15. I detailed cars before I could drive. If you had never seen one of the cars I worked over you had never seen a clean car. I would rock the toothbrush and q-tips for hours to earn my money. I'm now a photographer who works very hard for my money. I spend hours fine tuning images so that families can have memories for years and years, and I earn every penny.
-We need to lower the income tax for corporations.
I know, it hurts me even to type it. But if we don't do something about companies moving over seas for the tax benefits we're going to be in deep trouble. I'm not talking about subsidies, I'm talking about the income tax rates on a federal level.
- We need to stop with the double taxation.
Retired people who are collecting on social security shouldn't have to pay taxes on their benefits even if they are still earning income after they retire.
- Don't start wars unless Congress votes for it.
Hopefully we can stop electing morons to run our country before we have to do this again.
- We need to scrap the party systems and vote for people.
Too much loyalty comes from political parties. Loyalty isn't a bad thing, but when people vote for their parties' candidate even when they completely disagree with their views it's going overboard. The two party system rips America apart and creates an environment that makes it very difficult to get important things done.
- STOP FINANCING THE GOVERNMENT WITH CHINA'S MONEY
If you don't understand this one, go stick your head in a toilet, because that's where it belongs.
- We need less political correctness.
It's ridiculous and a waste of brain power to whine about somethign that's not PC.
- We need a more transparent government.
I hate to quote a trendy movie, but people shouldn't fear their governments, governments should fear their people. All the secrecy in the government is aimed at creating fear in order to incite mass loyalty.
- Let gay people have the same benefits as straight couples.
Whether you call it a marriage or a civil union, that's fine, but love is love, and if two HUMANS commit to each other for the rest of their lives then they deserve to have the same benefits as more politically correct couples.
- We need to respect peoples' private property and other personal rights.
Eminent domain needs to be struck down by the high courts. Just because a condo-complex will bring more tax revenue to a city than the row of small houses that sit on the land now doesn't give the city the right to seize the land and sell it to condo developers for a reduced price.
- Stop whining about people with guns.
I don't like guns, but I really don't trust the police to protect me. Strengthening gun control is fine, but radical liberals wanting all guns to be seized or destroyed need to realize that guns are here to stay, like it or not. Taking away guns from everybody isn't really taking away guns from everybody. Anybody worth their weight in cheesecloth can figure out that it wouldn't do a damn thing about guns within the gang, drug dealing, and general crime rings. It would just leave honest people defenseless.
- Stop worshiping celebrities.
Good God please stop caring about Paris Hilton's bajingo.
- Go to church
Any church. If not for the faith aspect, then for the therapeutic aspect. You don't have to believe in it to enjoy it.
There are many more reasons, but it 1:26 in the morning and I'm working on getting rid of a migraine.
But when it all comes down to it, as depressing as it is, change will not happen anytime soon (No matter what Barack Obama says).
The rich are always going to get richer, the politicians are always going to be greedy and corrupt, celebrities are always going to attract unnecessary attention, liberals are always going to hate conservatives, conservatives are always going to hate liberals, Rush Limbaugh is always going to be a fat artard, the government will always over-spend, people are always going to be jealous of people who have what they want, governments are always going to infringe on personal rights and be secretive, and people will always laugh at racial jokes in private but will always decry them in public.
What shall we do? You tell me. Leave a comment with your thoughts.
This is the battle-cry of the two remaining Democratic presidential candidates. Sounds good right?
I mean, think about it. Those damn richers make so much, and they're all evil. Every cent of their fortune is somehow stolen from us folks at the bottom. We need retribution! They make too much! They don't deserve it! KILL!
This little ditty is sung in many-a middle-class home. Should we blame them for thinking this way? No. I mean growing up I was always told that life isn't fair, and it isn't. But should we really be taxing the rich on general principle? I don't think so. There are so many loopholes in our much-too-extensive tax code for the rich. You know what I say? Stop bitching about it and fix it! I see the loopholes as a sort of built in, accidental anti-socialism device. But there is a serious injustice that the rich pay less than a lot of middle-class families do.
But what to do... What to do...
In a perfect world we wouldn't have the government taxing our money that we earn. But Ron Paul has no chance, so we can forget this.
How about the FairTax? I personally don't like it.
Taxes on consumption are regressive, but this is remedied by a tax pre-bate, making it a fairly progressive structure. It would most likely fall of near the top of the ladder and the middle-class would end up paying a bulk of the taxes.
The real reason I don't like it is admittedly a little selfish. I'm in college and due to student loans my net worth is in the red. I don't want to have to pay a 23% premium on my various retail purchases at this point in my life. Or ever really.
So what about the flat tax? A 10% federal flat tax on every earner's income. How about we sweeten the deal? Let's let everyone with an income lower than $35,000 pay no federal income taxes.
$0-$35,000: 0%
But wait, there's more. How about in the $35,000 to $80,000 bracket we only put that up to 5%
$0-$35,000: 0%
$35,001-$80,000: 5%
It gets better. Everything above $80,000 is taxed at 10%. No matter if you make $90,000 to $1.2 million.
Okay, so it's not a flat-tax anymore, but it's a nice compromise. Well hell, it's the only progressive tax I'd ever endorse.
What's that? You say it's not fair that someone can make more money than you and pay the same taxes? Suck it up and innovate. Work that brain of yours, find a way to better the world and make yourself a profit.
If you want to make millions but the corporate ladder is just too big, then quit your whining and do something productive. Don't just be jealous at the CEOs who make $38 million a year.
You say they're overpaid? Yeah they are. Why don't you buy some stock in the company and go to some stockholder conferences and express your concern.
Before we all cry out "tax the rich more" we need to be looking at all of the problems.
- The government needs to spend less. Yeah, this means cutting back on unnecessary programs, which includes a lot of wasteful social programs.
Before you go calling me a horrible person without a heart let me say this: I'm not against social programs for the truly needy, the truly disabled, or the truly sick. Medicare, Medicaid, Disability; I'm not against these. My father paid into the system his entire life and became medically disabled (the real kind, not the 'I slipped in Wal-Mart' kind). He's on disability. Anybody who pays into the system and can truly not work is entitled to the money they were forced to pay in. Medicare and Medicaid need to be managed more efficiently. Social security needs to be partially privatized. We need to stop electing people who are hemorrhaging our tax dollars away on pet projects and unnecessary wars.
- We need to stop with the jealousy.
It's an epidemic in this country. I'm a dirt poor 21 year old who's financing his college education. Have an image of me yet? Well, let me alter it. I've started up two business since I was 15. I detailed cars before I could drive. If you had never seen one of the cars I worked over you had never seen a clean car. I would rock the toothbrush and q-tips for hours to earn my money. I'm now a photographer who works very hard for my money. I spend hours fine tuning images so that families can have memories for years and years, and I earn every penny.
-We need to lower the income tax for corporations.
I know, it hurts me even to type it. But if we don't do something about companies moving over seas for the tax benefits we're going to be in deep trouble. I'm not talking about subsidies, I'm talking about the income tax rates on a federal level.
- We need to stop with the double taxation.
Retired people who are collecting on social security shouldn't have to pay taxes on their benefits even if they are still earning income after they retire.
- Don't start wars unless Congress votes for it.
Hopefully we can stop electing morons to run our country before we have to do this again.
- We need to scrap the party systems and vote for people.
Too much loyalty comes from political parties. Loyalty isn't a bad thing, but when people vote for their parties' candidate even when they completely disagree with their views it's going overboard. The two party system rips America apart and creates an environment that makes it very difficult to get important things done.
- STOP FINANCING THE GOVERNMENT WITH CHINA'S MONEY
If you don't understand this one, go stick your head in a toilet, because that's where it belongs.
- We need less political correctness.
It's ridiculous and a waste of brain power to whine about somethign that's not PC.
- We need a more transparent government.
I hate to quote a trendy movie, but people shouldn't fear their governments, governments should fear their people. All the secrecy in the government is aimed at creating fear in order to incite mass loyalty.
- Let gay people have the same benefits as straight couples.
Whether you call it a marriage or a civil union, that's fine, but love is love, and if two HUMANS commit to each other for the rest of their lives then they deserve to have the same benefits as more politically correct couples.
- We need to respect peoples' private property and other personal rights.
Eminent domain needs to be struck down by the high courts. Just because a condo-complex will bring more tax revenue to a city than the row of small houses that sit on the land now doesn't give the city the right to seize the land and sell it to condo developers for a reduced price.
- Stop whining about people with guns.
I don't like guns, but I really don't trust the police to protect me. Strengthening gun control is fine, but radical liberals wanting all guns to be seized or destroyed need to realize that guns are here to stay, like it or not. Taking away guns from everybody isn't really taking away guns from everybody. Anybody worth their weight in cheesecloth can figure out that it wouldn't do a damn thing about guns within the gang, drug dealing, and general crime rings. It would just leave honest people defenseless.
- Stop worshiping celebrities.
Good God please stop caring about Paris Hilton's bajingo.
- Go to church
Any church. If not for the faith aspect, then for the therapeutic aspect. You don't have to believe in it to enjoy it.
There are many more reasons, but it 1:26 in the morning and I'm working on getting rid of a migraine.
But when it all comes down to it, as depressing as it is, change will not happen anytime soon (No matter what Barack Obama says).
The rich are always going to get richer, the politicians are always going to be greedy and corrupt, celebrities are always going to attract unnecessary attention, liberals are always going to hate conservatives, conservatives are always going to hate liberals, Rush Limbaugh is always going to be a fat artard, the government will always over-spend, people are always going to be jealous of people who have what they want, governments are always going to infringe on personal rights and be secretive, and people will always laugh at racial jokes in private but will always decry them in public.
What shall we do? You tell me. Leave a comment with your thoughts.
Monday, February 4, 2008
Invest young or have fun and do it later?
I have many friends, but only two or three that actually invest. I see this as a major problem. This is directed towards my friends and other young people that aren't investing.
Consider this:
Most of my friends on myspace are a year or two above or below my age and a good portion of them have a job.
So what are you making? How much do you work?
I'll assume you work for $7.00 an hour, 28 hours a week. That's $196 per week before taxes. You get paid once every two weeks. We now have $392 before taxes. Last time I was working I had 17% taken out of my paycheck.
392(1-.17) = 325.36
So if you're getting $325 every two weeks what do you have to pay?
I'll take these two into consideration. I wouldn't expect a 20 year old living with their parents to pay much more.
Gas: ~$30 per week ($60 for two weeks)
Phone: ~$50 per month ($25 allotted every two weeks)
So that's $85 that needs to be taken out of every pay check. That leaves you with $240. If you're like me you like a beer with dinner, so that's about $10 a week. You'll need fast-food allotments; $25 for two weeks. You'll also need blow money; $60.
This leaves you with $135 from every paycheck.
Now I have no idea what your spending habits are, this is just a rough estimation.
Say you took that $135 and put the $35 into a savings account (to have emergency money on hand) and the remaining $100 into a growth stock mutual fund.
So every paycheck you'd be building your savings account with emergency money and you'd be funding a retirement account.
So what can $100 turn into if it's not spent on pointless things? Well, let's see:
Say we put the $200 a month (from two paychecks) of investing money into a mutual fund that averages 8% (a pretty conservative fund considering the overall average of the market has been almost 11% since it was created).
Let's fit this into the future value of an annuity equation.
$200 a month at 8% interest for, oh, let's say, 10 years.
200 being the monthly payment, .006666666667 being the interest rate (8%) adjusted in monthly increments, 120 being the amount of months in 10 years.
200 x ((1+.006666666667)^120-1)/.006666666667 = 36589.21
That comes out to $36,589.21 you'll have in 10 years.
$24,000 in principal, which means your $200 a month has earned $12,589 in 10 years. That might not seem like much, but it's a very conservative estimate considering your income will most likely grow considerably throughout those 10 years, enabling you to put more into the investment.
Say after the ten years you've kept to your guns and not gone into debt for silly things like TVs and other toys, and have managed to stay away from new cars (the number one mistake that college graduates make is buying the new car right when they get a job because they "deserve it") and you want to start investing more heavily into your future.
Now we're going to be hitting the market more aggressively.
$1200 a month into a mutual fund averaging 10% for 10 more years. We use the same formula.
1200 x ((1+.008333333333)^120-1)/.008333333333 = 245813.97
$245,814
Now include your previous investment that's been sitting in that same 8% fund for the past 10 years.
245,814 + (36589(1.08)^10) = $324,807
So you're 40 years old, have no debt other than a mortgage (unless you've managed to pay that down also!) and you've got a bitchin' emergency fund and $324,807 sitting there gathering that good ol' compound interest.
So you get a nice promotion and you keep sticking to your guns. You move all of your investments into that 10% fund and keep adding $2200 a month for 10 more years.
(324807(1.1)^10) + (2200 x (((1+.008333333333)^120-1)/.008333333333) = 1,293,124
That $1,293,124 at the ripe old age of 50.
You want to have $1.2 million when you're 50? We should all be so lucky. And if you want to retire at 60 and you let that $1.2 million compound at 10% for ten more years, you'll have $3,354,030. Without even adding anything for the last 10 years!
If you kept adding $2200 a month you'd have $3,804,688!
(If you upped the monthly payments to $3000 you'd have $3,968,565!)
Now let's tally up the amount you put into the investment.
The total principal if you invest for 10 years at $200 a month, 10 years at $1200 a month, and 20 more years at $2200 a month.
You would have put in a total of $432,000. That's an interest amount of almost $3.4 million dollars, all because you decided to start early and live like no one else so later you could live like no one else.
Say you plan on living to the age of 95. You've got a solid 35 years left. After you retire you could draw out $120,000 a year.
After today's capital gains tax (fancy way to say the government is stealing from your investment gains) of 15% you'll have approximately $102,000 before other federal, state and local taxes.
But the great thing is you could take out quite a bit more and still have your large nest-egg compounding in a safer, more conservative fund. There'll be plenty of money for you to live on, your healthcare, your funeral, and a little left over for donating or to give to your family.
My point is, Social Security isn't going to take care of you. You're going to have to start retiring sooner or later, and if it's later it'll be much harder to catch up. Buying stupid shit like new cars and other things is not going to help you in the long run.
Consider this:
Most of my friends on myspace are a year or two above or below my age and a good portion of them have a job.
So what are you making? How much do you work?
I'll assume you work for $7.00 an hour, 28 hours a week. That's $196 per week before taxes. You get paid once every two weeks. We now have $392 before taxes. Last time I was working I had 17% taken out of my paycheck.
392(1-.17) = 325.36
So if you're getting $325 every two weeks what do you have to pay?
I'll take these two into consideration. I wouldn't expect a 20 year old living with their parents to pay much more.
Gas: ~$30 per week ($60 for two weeks)
Phone: ~$50 per month ($25 allotted every two weeks)
So that's $85 that needs to be taken out of every pay check. That leaves you with $240. If you're like me you like a beer with dinner, so that's about $10 a week. You'll need fast-food allotments; $25 for two weeks. You'll also need blow money; $60.
This leaves you with $135 from every paycheck.
Now I have no idea what your spending habits are, this is just a rough estimation.
Say you took that $135 and put the $35 into a savings account (to have emergency money on hand) and the remaining $100 into a growth stock mutual fund.
So every paycheck you'd be building your savings account with emergency money and you'd be funding a retirement account.
So what can $100 turn into if it's not spent on pointless things? Well, let's see:
Say we put the $200 a month (from two paychecks) of investing money into a mutual fund that averages 8% (a pretty conservative fund considering the overall average of the market has been almost 11% since it was created).
Let's fit this into the future value of an annuity equation.
$200 a month at 8% interest for, oh, let's say, 10 years.
200 being the monthly payment, .006666666667 being the interest rate (8%) adjusted in monthly increments, 120 being the amount of months in 10 years.
200 x ((1+.006666666667)^120-1)/.006666666667 = 36589.21
That comes out to $36,589.21 you'll have in 10 years.
$24,000 in principal, which means your $200 a month has earned $12,589 in 10 years. That might not seem like much, but it's a very conservative estimate considering your income will most likely grow considerably throughout those 10 years, enabling you to put more into the investment.
Say after the ten years you've kept to your guns and not gone into debt for silly things like TVs and other toys, and have managed to stay away from new cars (the number one mistake that college graduates make is buying the new car right when they get a job because they "deserve it") and you want to start investing more heavily into your future.
Now we're going to be hitting the market more aggressively.
$1200 a month into a mutual fund averaging 10% for 10 more years. We use the same formula.
1200 x ((1+.008333333333)^120-1)/.008333333333 = 245813.97
$245,814
Now include your previous investment that's been sitting in that same 8% fund for the past 10 years.
245,814 + (36589(1.08)^10) = $324,807
So you're 40 years old, have no debt other than a mortgage (unless you've managed to pay that down also!) and you've got a bitchin' emergency fund and $324,807 sitting there gathering that good ol' compound interest.
So you get a nice promotion and you keep sticking to your guns. You move all of your investments into that 10% fund and keep adding $2200 a month for 10 more years.
(324807(1.1)^10) + (2200 x (((1+.008333333333)^120-1)/.008333333333) = 1,293,124
That $1,293,124 at the ripe old age of 50.
You want to have $1.2 million when you're 50? We should all be so lucky. And if you want to retire at 60 and you let that $1.2 million compound at 10% for ten more years, you'll have $3,354,030. Without even adding anything for the last 10 years!
If you kept adding $2200 a month you'd have $3,804,688!
(If you upped the monthly payments to $3000 you'd have $3,968,565!)
Now let's tally up the amount you put into the investment.
The total principal if you invest for 10 years at $200 a month, 10 years at $1200 a month, and 20 more years at $2200 a month.
You would have put in a total of $432,000. That's an interest amount of almost $3.4 million dollars, all because you decided to start early and live like no one else so later you could live like no one else.
Say you plan on living to the age of 95. You've got a solid 35 years left. After you retire you could draw out $120,000 a year.
After today's capital gains tax (fancy way to say the government is stealing from your investment gains) of 15% you'll have approximately $102,000 before other federal, state and local taxes.
But the great thing is you could take out quite a bit more and still have your large nest-egg compounding in a safer, more conservative fund. There'll be plenty of money for you to live on, your healthcare, your funeral, and a little left over for donating or to give to your family.
My point is, Social Security isn't going to take care of you. You're going to have to start retiring sooner or later, and if it's later it'll be much harder to catch up. Buying stupid shit like new cars and other things is not going to help you in the long run.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)